LawMeme LawMeme Yale Law School  
LawMeme
Search LawMeme [ Advanced Search ]
 
 
 
 
Features: Why Does Scientology Have a Copyright on the Truth?
Posted by Ernest Miller on Wednesday, August 28 @ 10:13:43 EDT Copyright
Politechbot published a recent position paper on copyright infringement from the media relations director for the Church of Scientology International (Scientology says it's threatened by "unadulterated cyber-terrorism"). The position paper attempts to justify Scientology's silencing of its critics via copyright law. Scientology objects to publication of its secret doctrines on the Internet and uses copyright law to get those documents removed from public view. What I've always wondered though, is why these documents are protected by copyright at all.

It seems to me that a claim of revealed truth for a particular work should exempt it from copyright law under the merger doctrine of idea/expression dichotomy. The idea/expression dichotomy ensures that facts and ideas cannot be copyrighted. Under the merger doctrine, if there is only one, or a few ways to express an idea, then the expression cannot be copyrighted because it would effectively give a monopoly over the idea, which is prohibited by the idea/expression dichotomy.

Shouldn't the merger doctrine apply to claims of revealed truth? My paraphrase of the Quran is not the Quran, and it would inevitably express an idea that is different than the idea expressed by the Quran itself. The idea and expression of the Quran are one and the same; my hypothetically adulterated Quran is simply not an acceptable substitute. The same applies to Scientology. Nothing but L. Ron Hubbard's own words is acceptable; you cannot change a single word without adulterating the facts of Scientology.

In court testimony, Warren McShane, President of the Religious Technology Center (holder of Scientology's copyrights), stated that:

There cannot be any alteration at all of Mr. Hubbard's work. The way he had laid it, there is an exact sequence of steps. It's very detailed, and there can't be any alteration to it.
Indeed, the RTC webpage makes this clear:
Past religious teachings, traditionally passed down by word of mouth or recorded by scribes, were subject to both alteration and misinterpretation. In contrast, this century’s technological advances have facilitated the permanent recording of Scientology scripture in books, tape-recorded lectures and films. Because the original writings and recordings by Mr. Hubbard can always be examined and verified, the technology, in truth, can never be lost.
Alteration is not permissible - the ideas expressed would not be the same.

There are many similar quotes from Scientologists, all making the point that L. Ron Hubbard discovered certain facts and his expression of these facts cannot be altered without changing the facts themselves. By its own admission then, Scientology is using copyright to maintain a monopoly over facts.

Of course, Scientology could avoid this dilemma by admitting either that, a) Scientology is not a fact or b) Paraphrases of Scientology materials are perfectly acceptable substitutes for the materials Scientology publishes.

 
Login
Nickname

Password

Don't have an account yet? You can create one. As a registered user you have some advantages like theme manager, comments configuration and post comments with your name.
Related Links
· Politechbot
· Church of Scientology International
· Scientology says it's threatened by "unadulterated cyber-terrorism"
· Scientology
· secret doctrines
· L. Ron Hubbard
· court testimony
· Religious Technology Center
· More about Copyright
· News by Ernest Miller


Most read story about Copyright:
Top Ten New Copyright Crimes

Options

Printer Friendly Page  Printer Friendly Page

Send to a Friend  Send to a Friend
"User's Login" | Login/Create an Account | 1 comment | Search Discussion
Threshold
  
The comments are owned by the poster. We aren't responsible for their content.

Re: Why Does Scientology Have a Copyright on the Truth? (Score: 0)
by Anonymous (Name Withheld on Advice of Counsel) on Wednesday, August 28 @ 12:16:54 EDT
Revelations 22:18-20 [www.bartleby.com]
18 ¶ For I testify unto every man that heareth the words of the prophecy of this book, If any man shall add unto these things, God shall add unto him the plagues that are written in this book:
19 and if any man shall take away from the words of the book of this prophecy, God shall take away his part out of the book of life, and out of the holy city, and from the things which are written in this book.


[ Reply to This ]


Leges humanae nascuntur, vivunt, moriuntur
Human laws are born, live, and die

All stories, comments and submissions copyright their respective posters.
Everything Else Copyright (c) 2002 by the Information Society Project.
This material may be distributed only subject to the terms and conditions set forth in the Open Publication License, v1.0 or later (the latest version is presently available at http://www.opencontent.org/openpub/).