LawMeme LawMeme Yale Law School  
LawMeme
Search LawMeme [ Advanced Search ]
 
 
 
 
Ernie Miller's 100th INDUCE Post
Posted by James Grimmelmann on Thursday, August 26 @ 20:53:10 EDT Copyright
Ernie Miller has been blogging relentlessly on the INDUCE Act; LawMeme has been maintaining an up-to-date index of his coverage. Today, Ernie reached his 100th post. I'd like to take this occasion to point out what are, in my subjective opinion, five highlights of his coverage:
  • One of Ernie's earliest and longest posts is also his best. The The Obsessively Annotated Introduction to the INDUCE Act is thorough debunking of the often-spurious logic behind the Act and a model of how to read a text closely while looking for holes in its argument.

  • Not far behind is Ernie's proposed replacement text. There have been other efforts, but Ernie's text really helped kick off public debate on how to fix INDUCE, not just bury it.

  • In third place is my favorite item from the brilliant Hatch's Hit List: Ernie's suggestion that universal Turing machines are blatant instruments of infringement, according to INDUCE's sloppy language and destructive nature.

  • With Hatch's Hit List, there are just so many gems from which to choose, but #6 -- Legos -- is particularly charming.

  • And hmm, I guess my fifth-favorite post is also from the Hit List. Dinging the U.S. Postal Service for inducing copyright infringement is just too cheeky to let pass without comment.

Stay tuned to the The LawMeme Reader's Guide to Ernie Miller's Guide to the INDUCE Act and to Mr. Miller himsef for continuing INDUCE (or is that INDUNCE?) news.
 
Related Links
· More about Copyright
· News by James Grimmelmann


Most read story about Copyright:
Top Ten New Copyright Crimes

Options

 Printer Friendly Page  Printer Friendly Page

 Send to a Friend  Send to a Friend

Threshold
The comments are owned by the poster. We aren't responsible for their content.

No Comments Allowed for Anonymous, please register

Financial Benefit under his Induce v2? (Score: 0)
by Anonymous on Friday, August 27 @ 01:03:29 EDT
I seem to remember that 'financial benefit' can include the receipt of other copyrighted works in return.

E.G. one might argue that, because some P2P network can be reasonably anticipated to make illicitly copied works more available, the developer, even making free of cost software, is still acting with some kind of financial incentive.

I seem to remember there are other ways in which "financial" benefits can be construed rather broadly. I mean, even ads on one's website might be enough.

Unless this is covered in the addition "under Subsections 106(3), 106(4) or 106(6) of this title" bits? I didn't look those up.



This was closely associated with the rebirth of (Score: 0)
by Anonymous on Saturday, October 02 @ 15:23:24 EDT
Serving on UCSA's board of directors, Gagnier supports the lawsuit, due to cuts to outreach programs that target students from low-income and minority families. Top Online Craps [top-online-casino.fateback.com] Best Webmoney Slots Directory [www.egold-casino.h12.ru] Domain Name Search [www.findspot.net] Dog Obedience [www.snomer.com] Xenical Uk [www.ownbody.com] Ecommerce Web Site Design Portal [www.phind.net] Sports Marketing [www.thispot.com] Top Online Roulette [top-online-casino.fateback.com] Top E Gold Blackjack [top-online-casino.fateback.com] Top Visa Mastercard Videopoker Catalog [e-gold-casino.b0x.com] Ecommerce Solutions [www.findspot.net] Dog Training Obedience [www.pbite.com] Web Design Company [www.phind.net] Training Your Dog [www.snomer.com] Bad Credit Loans [www.findish.com] Accounting Software [www.thispot.com] Sleep Apnea Equipment [www.makehelp.com] Association Of Pet Dog Trainers [www.snomer.com] Personal Time Management Software [www.thispot.com] E Gold Caribbean Poker [e-gold-casino.fateback.com] Top Visa Mastercard Blackjack Catalog [e-gold-casino.b0x.com] Best Goldmoney Craps Directory [www.egold-casino.h12.ru] Online Craps [e-gold-casino.fateback.com] E Gold Casino [e-gold-casino.fateback.com] Download Education [download-education.b0x.com] Top Webmoney Videopoker Catalog [e-gold-casino.b0x.com] Beagle Puppies [www.snomer.com] Healhome Com [www.healhome.com] Top Wmz Craps Catalog [e-gold-casino.b0x.com] Visa Mastercard Games [e-gold-casino.fateback.com] Top Evocash Caribbean Poker [top-online-casino.fateback.com] Obedience Training [www.pbite.com] Internet Sports Gambling [www.gofolks.com] Read the rest of this comment...



And now the description is wrong. (Score: 0)
by Anonymous on Wednesday, October 13 @ 06:43:50 EDT
Before raising the car tax, the state also has to be in a position where it is unable to borrow money, said McClintock, and neither was the case when Davis increased the tax. Pink Flowers [freeware-catalog.fateback.com] Pocket Inventory [play-online-casino.ds4a.com] Reccd [online-games-play.noneto.com] Crossword Power [games-online.fateback.com] Preg Dates [download-palm-freeware.yoll.net] 3d Biomolecula Pack [freeware-catalog.fateback.com] Devplanner [pda-games.undonet.com] Textmaker [get-freeware.b0x.com] Us Army Body Fat Percentage Calculator [download-palm-freeware.yoll.net] Aid Backup Master [online-games-play.noneto.com] Jtm Java Tree Menu [e-currency-casino.ds4a.com] Palm Greetings Caveman [free-download-palm.undonet.com] Spb Pocket Plus [free-download-palm.undonet.com] Sun Country Airlines [shareware-order-online.b0x.com] Index [get-shareware.trancetechno.com] Body Counter [download-palm-freeware.yoll.net] Tick [order-soft.deep-ice.com] Zilla Audio Converter Extractor [get-soft.koolhost.com] Winmessenger [shareware-order.sinfree.net] Sbutilities [free-download-palm.undonet.com] Activesync 3 1 [buyonline.ds4a.com] Binary Boy [free-download-pda.enacre.net] Lexikan [shareware-order.noneto.com] Tube New York City [soft-order.koolhost.com] Woman Calendar [order-shareware.b0x.com] Diabetes Pilot [order-shareware.b0x.com] Haunted House Diary [free-pda-games.yoll.net] Testinterp [online-games.sinfree.net] Printeron Pocketwhere [shareware-download.undonet.com] Netdecision [buy-online.yoll.net] Beam Screensaver [freeware-catalog.fateback.com] The Winery [download-pda-soft.sinfree.net] Navigator [softwarelink.siteburg.com] Sic Bo [play-casino-online.noneto.com] Read the rest of this comment...



it tells me i don't have (Score: 0)
by Anonymous on Friday, October 22 @ 19:57:00 EDT
Serving on UCSA's board of directors, Gagnier supports the lawsuit, due to cuts to outreach programs that target students from low-income and minority families. Health Nutrition [health-nutrition.bcure.com] Arthritis Treatment [arthritis-treatment.bcure.com] Diet [diet.bcure.com] Puppy Sale [puppy-sale.healz.com] Nutrition [nutrition.bcure.com] Asthma Diet [asthma-diet.healz.com] Asthma Cures [asthma-cures.healz.com] Rheumatoid Arthritis [rheumatoid-arthritis.bcure.com] Cures For Snoring [cures-for-snoring.bcure.com] Dogs [dogs.healz.com] Weight Loss Programs [weight-loss-programs.bcure.com] Bodybuilding Supplements [bodybuilding-supplements.healz.com] Low Carb Diet [low-carb-diet.bcure.com] Asthma Treatment [asthma-treatment.healz.com] Diets [diets.bcure.com] Atkins Diet [atkins-diet.bcure.com] Arthritis Relief [arthritis-relief.bcure.com] Apnea [apnea.bcure.com] Anabolic Steroid [anabolic-steroid.healz.com] Arthritis Pain Relief [arthritis-pain-relief.bcure.com] Weight Loss Diet [weight-loss-diet.bcure.com] Snoring [snoring.bcure.com] Dog Obedience [dog-obedience.healz.com] Nutrition Information [nutrition-information.bcure.com] Free Weight Loss [free-weight-loss.bcure.com] Puppies [puppies.healz.com] Training Your Dog [training-your-dog.healz.com] Juvenile Arthritis [juvenile-arthritis.bcure.com] Puppy [puppy.healz.com] Dog Agility Training [dog-agility-training.healz.com] Steroid Use [steroid-use.healz.com] Stop Dog Barking [stop-dog-barking.healz.com] Stop Snoring [stop-snoring.bcure.com] Weight Loss [weight-loss.bcure.com] Snoring Remedies [snoring-remedies.bcure.com] Puppy Training [puppy-training.healz.com] Anabolics [anabolics.healz.com] Arthritis [arthritis.bcure.com] Female Muscle [female-muscle.healz.com] Free Diet Plans [free-diet-plans.bcure.com] Anabolic Steroids [anabolic-steroids.healz.com] Dog Trainers [dog-trainers.healz.com] Muscle Men [muscle-men.healz.com] Rheumatoid Arthritis Treatment [rheumatoid-arthritis-treatment.bcure.com] Read the rest of this comment...



Okay, ik ga ze plaatsen op m'n web-log. :) (Score: 0)
by Anonymous on Wednesday, November 03 @ 00:54:51 EST
While the lawsuit claims that Schwarzenegger's repeal of the car tax was illegal, others have argued the opposite position. Senator Tom McClintock has argued that former Governor Gray Davis's tripling of the car tax was illegal. female bodybuilding [steroid-use.healz.com] dog training tips [dog-breeds.healz.com] dog training obedience [puppy.healz.com] snoring [snoring.bcure.com] training your dog [stop-barking.healz.com] dog agility training [dogs.healz.com] nutrition [low-carb-diet.bcure.com] nutrition [low-carb-diet.bcure.com] rheumatoid arthritis drug [rheumatoid-arthritis.bcure.com] dog training [puppy-training.healz.com] anabolic steroid information [anabolics.healz.com] sports steroids [anabolic-steroids.healz.com] female muscle [muscle.healz.com] free weight loss [diet-plan.bcure.com] snoring problem [anti-snoring.bcure.com] diet [atkins-diet.bcure.com] snoring [snoring.bcure.com] dog trainers [dog-training-schools.healz.com] information arthritis [arthritis-pain-relief.bcure.com] asthma cures [asthma-allergies.healz.com] steroid use [female-bodybuilding.healz.com] asthma symptoms [asthma.healz.com] bodybuilding supplements [bodybuilding.healz.com] weight loss [weight-loss.bcure.com] asthma diet [asthma-cures.healz.com] snoring treatments [sleep-apnea-cause.bcure.com] training your dog [stop-barking.healz.com] sports steroids [anabolic-steroids.healz.com] low carb diet [nutrition-information.bcure.com] asthma drugs [asthma-diet.healz.com] information arthritis [arthritis-pain-relief.bcure.com] nutrition information [diets.bcure.com] steroid use [female-bodybuilding.healz.com] asthma [asthma-symptoms.healz.com] asthma diet [asthma-cures.healz.com] diet [atkins-diet.bcure.com] steroid use [female-bodybuilding.healz.com] arthritis pain relief [rheumatoid-arthritis-drug.bcure.com] anti snoring [snoring-treatments.bcure.com] puppy training [dog-agility-training.healz.com] puppy training [dog-agility-training.healz.com] free weight loss [diet-plan.bcure.com] nutrition [low-carb-diet.

Read the rest of this comment...



And now the description is wrong. (Score: 0)
by Anonymous on Friday, March 25 @ 07:36:40 EST
The implied threat of punishment for any infraction was enough to overcome our nervousness, so we dutifully followed them into the bar Mod_pcgi2 [unix-internet-authoring.bw-news.com] When I stepped out, Ocean Life [windows-screen-savers-misc.bw-news.com] When I stepped out, Amosistechnik Font For Pc [windows-graphics-fonts.bw-news.com] When I stepped out, Ie Companion [windows-internet-browser.bw-news.com] When I stepped out, Graphico [unix-development-tools-libraries.bw-news.com] I can still remember the day a tear stained four year old had asked if what an older child had tauntingly told her was true, that there was no Santa Clause



PLease, how Can i download. (Score: 0)
by Anonymous on Friday, March 25 @ 17:47:20 EST
I gave a polite curtsy, then left to clean my inside as well as the outside of my body Siglab [unix-education-computers.bw-news.com] Pleasure is about gr Ncursesacarsdclient [unix-audio-editors.bw-news.com] Pleasure is about gr Mailblink [unix-internet-mail.bw-news.com] Pleasure is about gr Side Effects [windows-education-health.bw-news.com] Pleasure is about gr Im Multi System Mobile Instant Messenger [epoc-wireless-communications.tabrays.com] My nose is a faucet, and my throat is pretty sore



What?, don't they know who we are? (Score: 0)
by Anonymous on Tuesday, March 29 @ 16:26:09 EST
The other dishes scattered about the table ranged for unpalatable to inedible Plumper [fattygirl.erospace.pl] She pushed the needl Hairy Armpits [hairypussy.allbreast.com] She pushed the needl Plumpers [fattygirl.w5.pl] She pushed the needl Free Plumper Movies [fatty.pleasekiss.us] She pushed the needl Fat Belly [fattygirl.xxxnations.com] James was still sitting naked on the couch finishing his beer



Zucht. En ik heb al zo'n last van frequent lozen van flatus en RSI. (Score: 0)
by Anonymous on Thursday, March 31 @ 12:30:32 EST
But if that thought was going to cause resistance, the picture of the poor, sobbing, miserable girl in front of me was more than enough to convince me that Hairy Teen [hairypussy.sexushost.com] Finally, she had aga Shemale Cartoons [tranny.allbisexual.com] Finally, she had aga Hairy Girl [hairypus.w5.pl] Finally, she had aga Fat Girls [fatty.pleasekiss.us] Finally, she had aga Hairy Sex [hairypussy.sexushost.com] The Mistresses were talking calmly but were obviously anticipating an exciting evening



For some reason, (Score: 0)
by Anonymous on Sunday, April 03 @ 05:02:26 EDT
Pat said, We are going to sleep in the guest room tonight, Chris and Brian wish to be alone Hairy Girls [gorbun.selectedsex.com] The soft voice seeme Plump [crocus.sexushost.com] The soft voice seeme Free Shemale Pictures [mybest.analloverz.com] The soft voice seeme Family Incest [globuss.sexushost.com] The soft voice seeme Fat Women [balbes.t35.com] Later I watched the news while she dozed on her stomach before the TV



Leges humanae nascuntur, vivunt, moriuntur
Human laws are born, live, and die
grotesque-variorum

LawMeme articles published after May 1, 2005 are subject to the Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 2.0 License.

Contributors retain copyright interests in all comments and stories or submissions on or before May 1, 2005.
Access to material before May 1, 2005 is subject to the terms and conditions
set forth in the Open Publication License, v1.0. grotesque-variorum

The PHP-Nuke engine on which LawMeme runs is copyright by PHP-Nuke, and is freely available under the GNU GPL.
Everything else is copyright copyright 2002-05 by the Information Society Project.

You can syndicate our news with backend.php



Page Generation: 0.276 Seconds